Promoting Reflection and its Effect on Learning in a Programming Tutor
نویسنده
چکیده
We studied the effect of post-practice reflection on learning, using programming tutors, and multiple-choice format for reflection. We conducted in-vivo controlled studies with introductory programming students from multiple schools over 3 semesters, and used mixed-factor ANOVA to analyze the collected data. We found that reflecting on the concept underlying each problem neither promotes greater learning, measured as pre-post increase in the average score per problem, nor promotes faster learning, measured as the problems solved per concept learned. We conjecture that the benefits of reflecting on the concept underlying each problem may be limited if a tutor already promotes deep understanding of the domain.
منابع مشابه
Cognitive Mastery Learning in the ACT Programming Tutor
The ACT Programming Tutor (APT) is a problem solving environment constructed around an executable cognitive model of the programming knowledge students are acquiring. This cognitive model supports two types of adaptive instructional processes. First, it enables the tutor to follow each student’s solution path through complex problem solving spaces, providing appropriate assistance as needed. Se...
متن کاملWhich is effective: self-directed learning or tutor-directed learning on the level of nursing skills
Introduction. This is quasi experimental research in order to determine and compare the learning level of nursing skills ( in B.A students) with self-directed learning and tutor-directed learning pattern in Shaheed Beheshti Univeristy of Medical Sciences and Health Services, Nursing and Midwifery faculty, 1998-1999. Methods. First of all, a questionnaire composed of some demographic data such ...
متن کاملThe Effect of Family Nursing Education Using Reflection Method with the Help of Situation Simulation Through Video Screening on Learning and Perspective of Nursing Students
Introduction: Reflection is one of the basic methods of education that is effective in raising the level of awareness and skills in clinical situations. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of family nursing education using reflection method with the help of situation simulation through video screening on learning and perspective of nursing students. Methods: This quasi-experimen...
متن کاملOn Anthropomorphism in Technology-Enhanced Language Learning: Does Modality Matter in Agent-Based Multimedia Instruction on L2 Idioms?
The present study aimed to satisfy a twofold purpose: On the one hand, it sought to verify the postulation that agent-based instruction could offer a compromise approach to teaching L2 idioms where form and meaning would be equally emphasized during instruction. Given that anthropomorphism has not been much under scrutiny, this research, on the other hand, sought to ascertain whether learning a...
متن کاملA Pedagogical Assistant for Learning Object-Oriented Design: Nagging Students into Self- Reflection
We discuss our design for implementing a computer-based tutor for learning object-oriented design. Traditional ITS techniques do not transfer well to open-ended tasks such as information systems modelling. Some have also argued that such systems take away many tasks, which are important for learners to carry out themselves, like error analysis and self-reflection Furthermore we build on the ass...
متن کامل